Does “Everything Happen For A Reason”?

chocolateyraspberry asked:

Hey, I’m not sure how to ask this but lately I’ve been wavering in my faith and trying to come back. But one thing I’ve been struggling with is the concept of “everything happening for a reason.” What are your opinions concerning that? Also, what are your opinions on rape and who it occurs to and why? By the way, I love your blog and what God is using you to do, it’s amazing and thank you for being a light 🙂

Hey there my dear friend. Thank you so much for your kind message.

You know, over the last few years, I’ve come around to no longer believe that “everything happens for a reason.” I think it’s a very cute proposition that might help us for a while, but it starts to fall apart when you read the news or your child gets cancer or there’s an earthquake that kills millions or your friend is sexually abused or your dad has chronic pain for the rest of his life.

All this means that the world is horribly broken and nothing is really as it’s meant to be. As C.S. Lewis said, “Nothing is yet in its true form.” It means we live in the irretrievable whirlwind of death and loss and nostalgia and permanent “gone-ness” — so to pull lessons from these things minimizes our humanity.

If you talk to anyone who’s involved in such a huge tragedy, you can’t say those cute cliches like “Pain forces you to grow” or “God has a wonderful plan for your life.” It sounds hollow and stupid, and I would slap myself in the face if I said those things too.

I believe more and more that not every pain has a lesson. I think sometimes that pain is just pain, that life can be a mystery, and it’s all part of our weird wild crazy human experience. Pain is part of being human. We don’t need to spiritualize everything. We don’t need to wrap things up with a bowtie. Sometimes there is unresolved tension and we need to let it bleed.

However, here’s why I believe in the Christian faith.

I believe in Jesus because his life means God actually showed solidarity with us in our pain. I know that doesn’t solve pain right now. But when I’m hurting, I don’t need a lecture or a connect-the-dots-theology. What I need is a friend who will stay with me side by side and hear my venting, embrace my shaking, love me through my slobbery flailing mess. I need a presence who both understands my pain but is just enough above it to lead me through it.

And if I believe the narrative of Jesus, then we have both a person who has been through what I’ve been through and a divine presence who can help pull me through the worst of it. Jesus on a cross showed an unresolved tension that bled — but Jesus out of a tomb showed there really is a bowtie to this whole thing, a far-off nearly imperceptible light at the end of this tunnel.

Maybe we will find out the “reasons” one day for why everything happened. Maybe they will satisfy us, or not. But by then, the answers probably won’t matter anymore. Because we’ll be face to face with the God who was with us all along, the only one who never left us in our mess and who truly understood us as we are, venting and angry and hurting and all, and we’ll find out He really did love us despite us, and He suffered infinitely more than we could ever bear to face on our own.

I hold onto this hope. It feels foolish some days: but on those days, it’s all I have and all I need.

— J.S.

8 thoughts on “Does “Everything Happen For A Reason”?

  1. That is a great answer to a tough question. There are times when, yes, I think we have something to learn. The rest of the time, well life is life whether you are Christian or not.

    Like you, I’ve ranted and raved when I’ve been completely bewildered and angry at stuff happening in my life or another’s that is painful, unjust and awful. I think God is big enough to take our rantings to be honest. Look at Psalms. David told God what he thought. So did Job.

    But it’s what happens at the other end of it, if indeed, there is an end, that God looks for. Will we continue to hold onto Him even if we don’t get the answers, we don’t see an end to the hurt, suffering, injustice etc?

    Love the way you write.


    1. Thank you my friend. I know that even these words are not adequate to help anyone who is truly suffering, because really our human language is so limited to console someone in extreme pain. I went from a simplistic “Let go and let God” kind of theology to a much more silent presence during pain. I think we can only get there after surviving trials too. Thanks for your kind words and your thoughtfulness. 🙂


  2. I agree, I cannot believe God “causes” everything; we have to take some responsibility. But I still think God can work something good out of anything, even if it is, as you say, to bleed.


  3. I wanted to write something like this after my wreck but I didn’t have the words. I read a lot and searched though. So I’m adding this link to a post with other links about God and why bad things happen. Thanks for the encouragement! God bless bro!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.